Plant Protein vs Animal Protein: How Much Do We Need?

Plant, animal, red meat, white meat or protein powder? They may all provide protein, but they don’t provide the same nutritional package.

A customer recently asked us a seemingly simple question:

“Which protein is better — plant or animal?”

Protein has become one of the most marketed nutrients in our food. We count protein grams, buy high-protein foods and increasingly add protein powders to our diets.

But perhaps we are asking the wrong question.

It isn’t only how much protein we eat that matters. It is also where that protein comes from — and what comes with it.

Protein Sources

First: How Much Protein Do We Actually Need Per Day?

For most healthy adults, a useful benchmark for daily protein requirements is around 0.8–0.83 g of protein per kg of body weight per day.

That means approximately:

  • 60 kg adult → 48–50 g/day

  • 70 kg adult → 56–58 g/day

  • 80 kg adult → 64–66 g/day

Men therefore often require more protein in absolute grams simply because average body weight and lean mass are greater — not because men and women have fundamentally different protein requirements per kilogram.

Children need proportionately more protein during growth, with requirements changing with age and body weight. Pregnancy, lactation, older age, athletic training and illness can also alter requirements.

Kidney disease is an important exception to the idea that more protein is always better. The 2024 KDIGO guidelines recommend around 0.8 g/kg/day for adults with CKD stages G3–G5 — broadly an eGFR below 60 — and advise avoiding high protein intakes above 1.3 g/kg/day in people with CKD at risk of progression. More substantial protein restriction is sometimes considered in advanced kidney disease, but this should be done with medical and dietetic supervision because excessive restriction can lead to muscle loss and malnutrition. So if you have significant kidney disease, don’t simply start a high-protein diet or protein supplements because “protein is healthy” — your protein intake should be calculated according to your individual needs.

Plant Protein vs Animal Protein: Is Animal Protein Better Because It Is “Complete”?

This is one of the most persistent misconceptions about plant protein.

Proteins are made from amino acids, nine of which we need to obtain from our diet. Animal proteins generally contain all the essential amino acids in favourable proportions.

But that doesn’t mean a plant-based diet cannot provide all the essential amino acids.

Different plants contain different proportions of amino acids. Across a varied diet containing foods such as lentils, beans, chickpeas, soy, nuts, seeds and grains, these complement one another. They don’t even need to be carefully “combined” at every meal.

And one plant deserves particular mention:

Soy is an excellent plant-based protein food.

Soy has a particularly strong essential amino-acid profile and high protein quality. Foods such as tofu, tempeh, edamame and whole soybeans can provide substantial amounts of high-quality protein. For most people, whole soy foods are an excellent addition to the diet.

But Protein Quality Is Not Just About Protein Content

This is perhaps the most important point.

Imagine eating 20 g of protein from four different sources.

20 g from lentils or soy may arrive with fibre, polyphenols, minerals and predominantly unsaturated fats.

20 g from fish or chicken provides excellent-quality protein and several important micronutrients. Fish can additionally provide beneficial omega-3 fats.

20 g from fatty red meat may come with considerably more saturated fat and no fibre.

And 20 g from a protein isolate may give you exactly what its name suggests — lots of isolated protein, but much less of the original food around it.

So although the nutrition label may say 20 g protein in every case, metabolically and nutritionally these foods are not identical.

Whole Plant-Based Protein Sources Bring Something Extra

Lentils, beans, chickpeas, soy, nuts and seeds aren’t simply “sources of protein.”

They also provide fibre, polyphenols, antioxidants, minerals and numerous other plant compounds.

This matters.

Fibre feeds our gut microbiome and its fermentation can produce beneficial metabolites such as short-chain fatty acids. Plant-rich diets are also associated with favourable cardiometabolic and inflammatory profiles.

In other words, when you eat a bowl of dal, the amino acids are only part of the story.

Your gut bacteria are getting fed too.

This is one reason we favour the concept of whole-food protein rather than isolated protein.

So Is Animal Protein Unhealthy?

No. That would be far too simplistic.

The type of animal protein matters enormously.

Fish is not chicken. Chicken is not mutton. Mutton is not salami.

Fish and unprocessed white meat such as chicken can be excellent protein sources, particularly when prepared without large amounts of saturated fat.

Red meat is different. It can provide protein, iron, zinc and vitamin B12, but depending on the cut it can also contain substantial saturated fat.

And processed meat deserves its own category altogether.

The International Agency for Research on Cancer classifies processed meat as carcinogenic to humans (Group 1), based particularly on evidence for colorectal cancer. Red meat is classified as probably carcinogenic (Group 2A).

That doesn’t mean eating one sausage causes cancer. Risk relates to exposure over time.

But it is another reason why sausages, salami, bacon and other processed meats shouldn’t be our everyday protein strategy.

Plant Protein vs Animal Protein: What Does the Long-Term Research Show?

Large observational studies provide an interesting picture.

A BMJ systematic review and meta-analysis included more than 715,000 people. Higher plant-protein intake was associated with lower all-cause and cardiovascular mortality. In its dose-response analysis, replacing a greater proportion of dietary energy with plant protein was associated with lower mortality. Animal protein overall did not show a significant association with mortality — again reminding us that simply labelling all animal protein as “bad” would be incorrect.

The more useful message is:

Shifting some of our protein from red and processed meats towards whole plant sources appears to be a sensible long-term health strategy.

What About Whey Protein and Plant Protein Isolates?

Protein powders have their place.

Whey, soy isolate and pea protein can be extremely convenient for athletes, older people, people recovering from illness or anyone struggling to meet their protein requirements through food.

But we should distinguish a protein supplement from a protein-rich whole food.

Processing milk into whey protein or soybeans into soy isolate concentrates the protein while removing much of the original food matrix.

Compare:

Whole soybean → protein + fibre + healthy fats + micronutrients + phytochemicals

versus

Soy protein isolate → predominantly concentrated protein

The isolate isn’t inherently “bad”. It simply isn’t nutritionally equivalent to the whole food it came from.

Protein powder can supplement food. It doesn’t need to replace it.

India Already Has an Extraordinary Pantry of Vegetarian Protein Sources

This conversation is particularly relevant in India, where vegetarian diets and plant-based meals have been part of our food culture for centuries.

Dal, chana, rajma, soy, sattu, peanuts, almonds, seeds and whole grains can all contribute meaningful amounts of protein.

A cup of cooked lentils can provide around 15–18 g, a cup of chickpeas around 14–15 g, while soy foods can be particularly protein dense.

The problem isn’t vegetarianism.

A vegetarian diet based predominantly on polished rice, refined flour and potatoes can be relatively protein-poor. A vegetarian diet rich in pulses, legumes, soy, nuts, seeds and diverse whole grains is something entirely different.

This philosophy is also part of why we formulated Ruby Roti the way we did.

Two Ruby Rotis, made from approximately 54 g of flour, provide around 20 g of protein — but we didn’t want to simply add an isolated protein powder to achieve that number.

The formulation uses more than 16 plant ingredients, providing protein from diverse whole-food sources alongside approximately 14 g of fibre.

And because metabolic health isn’t just about protein, the formulation was developed alongside its glycaemic properties: Ruby Roti has been clinically tested for its post-meal glucose and insulin response.

The objective was never simply:

“How can we put 20 g of protein into two rotis?”

It was:

“What else should come with those 20 grams?”

Veg Protein

Plant-Based Protein and Sustainability: There Is Another Beneficiary, the Planet

Our choice of protein affects more than our bodies.

The 2025 EAT-Lancet Commission again places plant-rich eating patterns at the centre of diets designed to support both human health and a sustainable food system. Food production places enormous pressure on climate, land, water and biodiversity, and the environmental footprint varies considerably between foods.

Moving towards more legumes, pulses, nuts and other plant proteins, while moderating particularly red meat consumption, therefore offers something unusual in nutrition:

A choice that can be good for human health and better aligned with planetary health.

For India, perhaps this isn’t even a revolutionary idea.

It may simply mean rediscovering and improving upon something our food culture has been doing for generations.

So, Which Protein Is Best: Plant or Animal?

There doesn’t need to be a battle between “plant” and “animal.”

For everyday eating, make whole plant proteins — dals, beans, chickpeas, soy, nuts and seeds — the foundation.

If you eat animal foods, fish, eggs, appropriate dairy and unprocessed white meat can all contribute excellent-quality protein.

Eat red meat less frequently and minimise processed meats.

Use whey and protein isolates when they genuinely help you meet a need, rather than assuming that a scoop of concentrated protein is nutritionally superior to food.

Most importantly, the next time you turn over a packet and look at the protein number, don’t stop at:

“How many grams of protein does this contain?”

Ask one more question:

“What else comes with my protein?”

Because ultimately, we don’t eat nutrients.

We eat food.